BBC seek to explain murder sentences…but get the law a bit wrong

BBC seek to explain murder sentences…but get the law a bit wrong

1
SHARE

This morning, 11 December 2013, the BBC News website published an article by Jon Kelly seeking to explain the reason why three men convicted of murder received mandatory life sentences with wildly different minimum terms.

The three cases

Lee James: 18 years

Rakesh Bhayani: 27 years

Anxiang Du: 40 years

We are of course wholly in favour of greater public legal education, particularly the explanation of criminal cases featuring in the news (indeed, we have been doing it for over a year). This piece provides a good, brief, explanation of each of the sentencing decisions, with a couple of comments from two esteemed practitioners and an esteemed academic.

As a part of the article, Jon Kelly sought to explain how the starting points for the calculation of minimum terms in murder cases are calculated (while we’re at it, here is our fact sheet).

Getting the law a bit wrong

The problem is, Jon Kelly gets the law slightly wrong. Here, he states that the starting points for life apply to offenders aged 21+

 BBC Sch 21

There are three problems.

The starting points – who do they apply to?

Firstly, the Sch 21 starting points apply only to murder convictions. Jon states they apply ‘to life’. There are four types of life sentence available to the courts in England and Wales. These starting points only apply to mandatory life sentences imposed for murder.

Secondly, the starting points differ depending on the age of the offender. The correct explanation is as follows:

Whole life: Only available for those 21+

30 years: Available for those 18+

25 years: Available for those 18+

15 years: Available for those 18+

12 years: The only starting point for offenders aged under 18

[See Criminal Justice Act 2003 Sch 21 paras 4, 5, 5A, 6 and 7] The explanation as to which starting point applies to which case (e.g. bringing  a knife or other weapon to the scene, 25 years) was correct.

And thirdly, that he fails to state that the offender’s age is at the time of the offence, not conviction or sentence.

In a post seeking to explain the law, getting the law wrong is not a great start (though we applaud the desire to improve public understanding).

For the future, if the BBC wanted to have such articles etc. checked pre-publication, we would be more than willing to do so. Just drop us an email. What a service!

SHARE
Lyndon is the General Editor of Current Sentencing Practice and the Criminal Appeal Reports (Sentencing)

1 COMMENT

  1. Twist the hair when you chalk. The feel from twisting makes the chalk
    launch far more pigment.

    Always remember to brush the excess powder out soon after chalking
    every piece.

    If you’re blonde or you have blonde tips, DO NOT wet your
    hair before chalking. If you do because adding water to pure pigment creates a real dye, i will stain.
    If you’re okay with the staining for several
    washes then go for it! If you’re looking to do color for the day, do not add water at
    any time.

    If your hair color is anything darker than blonde and you don’t
    have blonde tips, you’ll NEED the water.

    Doubling the pigment is the thing that can help the colors to
    be visible on darker locks. Mist a bit water on the strand having
    a mist bottle, then chalk it up! It will not blemish dark-colored your hair
    much the same way it is going to on lighter weight hair.

    Red heads- try it without water and if it’s just not showing up, add a
    little water. It just is determined by how light or darkish
    your red-colored is.

    Only use “soft pastels”. These are typically our all time faves.
    Senellier manufacturer pastels hold the
    smartest and the majority of intense be worthwhile we have at any time
    we’ve and seen… tried a whole lot. So
    is hair color- and hair color removal, even
    though they’re nearly $4 per piece at Blick, which seems a little expensive.
    Standard chalk doesn’t operate exactly the same. It’s tougher to shift and obtaining it to adhere to your locks may be almost difficult.

    Delicate chalk pastels is available at any main craft retailer.

    Just do not get “soft chalk” pastels confused
    for gas pastels. If you’re confused, ask a sales person.

    Getting rid of gas pastels might be a headache,
    in addition to, they’d feel totally tacky.

LEAVE A REPLY